ChatGPT gets your homework done. Then tanks your exam score.
In a high school study published in PNAS, high school maths students practised with standard GPT-4 or without AI—then took a closed-book exam with zero AI assistance.
During practice
+48%higher scores with GPT-4vs. no AI
Score out of 100
50250
No AI
28.4
Standard AI
42.1+13.7 pts
On the unassisted test
−17%lower scores after GPT-4 practicevs. no AI
Score out of 100
50250
No AI
32.1
Standard AI
26.7−5.4 pts
Source: Bastani et al. (2025), PNAS. Scores out of 100 on intentionally challenging high school maths problems. Standard AI estimates combine the no-AI means with the adjusted effects in Table 1.
The problem
Who’s actually doing the thinking?
English · Fiction extractElla folded her speech notes into smaller and smaller squares.
Asking standard AI
You
What does this line tell us about Ella? Write the answer for me.
Standard AI
Ella seems nervous about giving her speech. She keeps folding her notes to give her hands something to do.
You have a paragraph to hand in. When you read a new passage, which words will you pick as evidence?
Working with Tiplo Tutor
You
I think Ella’s nervous. I noticed “smaller and smaller”, but I’m stuck on how to explain it.
Tiplo
Read it once with just “small squares”. What does the repetition in the original make you picture Ella’s hands doing?
We’re here to help you find your own reading. Pick a detail, explain what it suggests, then try the same skill on a fresh passage.
Explore Tiplo’s six steps →
In the maths study above, students often asked the standard chatbot for answers and copied them. The researchers suggest this missed practice helps explain the lower closed-book exam scores. Read the study
How Tiplo works
Learn a method you can use again.
What do you give up when you make a choice? Follow an economics question from a school fair to a town budget.
01 · Attempt
Make the first call
Your class can run one stall at the school fair. It picks the bakery. What is the opportunity cost of that choice?
The class’s preferences
1stBakery
2ndBooks
3rdPlants
“We gave up two stalls. Do I count both?”
02 · Discover
Ask for a hint
Tiplo asks you to imagine the bakery is unavailable. Look at the two stalls you could still run.
Tiplo’s hint
2nd Books3rd Plants
“Which stall would your class actually choose next?”
03 · Explain
Say why the second choice matters
Your class would have sold books if it couldn’t run the bakery. Explain what the class gives up in your own words.
Your explanation
Opportunity costThe value of the book stall
“Books come next in our ranking. We could only run one stall.”
04 · Recall
Try a fresh choice on your own
Ari has time for one museum visit. He chooses fossils and would otherwise see the stars. What has he given up?
One museum visit
First pickFossilsNext pickStars
“The chance to see the stars.”
05 · Apply
Use the idea in a town budget
A town can fund one project. It chooses a cycle path. Use the council’s ranking to explain the opportunity cost to a resident.
The council’s priorities
1stCycle path
2ndBenches
3rdMural
“People give up the places to rest that the benches would provide.”
06 · Review
Test what you remember
Revisit the school fair with one detail changed. The bakery still comes first, but plants move ahead of books. How does your answer change?
Back at the fair
New second choicePlant stall
“Now the value of running the plant stall is what we give up.”
For every 1 step to the right, the line rises 1 step. Try a different slope.
Your progress is based on what you can do independently. Hints and worked answers help you learn, but do not count as doing it alone.
Your progress
What you can do on your own, what to do next, and where you stand on each topic.
How your lessons felt
No lessons yet
After a lesson, tell your tutor what feels clear and what needs more practice.
Can do alone and Needs work come only from answers checked by the computer, and help counts against them. Questions you ask, answers written for you, videos you watch and what you say about a lesson are shown, but never counted as mastery.
Your lesson
This video only. Set future speaking pace in Settings.